Friends of Fulham

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: dannyboi-ffc on June 27, 2016, 09:56:54 PM

Title: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: dannyboi-ffc on June 27, 2016, 09:56:54 PM
As a Fulham fan I love Roy but that was undefendable. Those players are an embarrassment and once again when we needed a saviour Rooney was useless. Funny enough I've always defended Rooney too but he proved tonight he is old and not a top class player.

I would even go as far as to say Hodgson is the worst manager in my lifetime. Worse than McClaren as he's now failed in 3 consecutive Dire tournaments.

Clueless! The lot of them. And they say never go back, well after that I don't want to go back. I'd rather just keep the good memories.

I hope Iceland win it, at least they CARE about their country.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: YoungsBitter on June 27, 2016, 10:02:39 PM
Very depressing. They do seem to be totally shorn of any confidence and if the coach cant get them to believe then he needs to leave and that was obvious tonight and the other games. Kane and corners? Wilshere? some very strange judgement calls.
Lovely guy but time to go.
As for Rooney, he stunk the place up tonight, left in too long but sadly there were 6 others as bad...
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Mince n Tatties on June 27, 2016, 10:07:40 PM
Quote from: YoungsBitter on June 27, 2016, 10:02:39 PM
Very depressing. They do seem to be totally shorn of any confidence and if the coach cant get them to believe then he needs to leave and that was obvious tonight and the other games. Kane and corners? Wilshere? some very strange judgement calls.
Lovely guy but time to go.
As for Rooney, he stunk the place up tonight, left in too long but sadly there were 6 others as bad...

Overpaid bunch of players
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: dannyboi-ffc on June 27, 2016, 10:09:12 PM
That's the thing, not taking Drinkwater, taking Wilshere, not taking Townsend or any winger for that matter, Kane on set pieces when he's our target man?????? And after seeing him be useless at them for 3 games we continue with him. Rooney marking their best header of the ball for a long throw and then continuing to mark him for every other throw.

There was no learning your lesson, nothing. He made his decisions and you live and die by them when they are as odd as Roys and imo he has been rewarded as going down in history as the manager who got outplayed and beaten by Iceland.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Zendra on June 27, 2016, 10:14:22 PM
These players get built up by our media as superstars just because clubs are stupid enough to pay the useless clowns ridiculous amounts of money .  Fulham would beat Iceland 19 times out of 20  because our players know its the end if Fulham get rid of them.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Sgt Fulham on June 27, 2016, 10:15:50 PM
Calling this an embarrassment gives ourselves too much credit. We aren't a top team when the pressure is on. When the pressure is off we have all the talent in the world but they just lack the winning mentality. Sad to see it end this way.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: gang on June 27, 2016, 10:19:01 PM
I don't think resignation comes into it he will be sacked, that was made obvious after the last game when the Powers To Be totally ignored him.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: westcliff white on June 27, 2016, 10:19:03 PM
Walker and Hart at fault for the goals, but once behind we never looked like scoring. Rash ford should of been on for the last 15 at least. Very disappointing
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Sgt Fulham on June 27, 2016, 10:20:59 PM
Quote from: Zendra on June 27, 2016, 10:14:22 PM
These players get built up by our media as superstars just because clubs are stupid enough to pay the useless clowns ridiculous amounts of money .  Fulham would beat Iceland 19 times out of 20  because our players know its the end if Fulham get rid of them.

Haha I get your point but the Fulham of last season couldn't beat an egg!
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: YoungsBitter on June 27, 2016, 10:21:09 PM
He just resigned 049:gif
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Sgt Fulham on June 27, 2016, 10:22:49 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

I'm supporting Germany now actually. I'm fed up of supporting losing sides.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: dannyboi-ffc on June 27, 2016, 10:23:54 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

I won't be supporting Wales, I'm not Welsh, I dont wish bad on them either, they just mean nothing to me. I come from an Italian family so its them or Iceland for me.

And you're a one man team. Difference is we are just a half hearted sh1t team full of bottle jobs who can't handle the pressure. Wales have nothing to lose
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: westcliff white on June 27, 2016, 10:28:51 PM
Well said dannyboi on both points. To effort.

England out so my support is over, like to see Italy do well as they look a proper team and have 11 good players on the pitch
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: ..Kya.ffc.. on June 27, 2016, 10:43:22 PM
As much as I would want England to do well for you all, Iceland have my support. When my native country couldn't qualify, Iceland is as close as can be for me.

Simply brilliant that the managed this, the smallest country by far only 330k in population and yet they are still in it. What's not to like?

If you can't beat them, join them, Iceland all the way!
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: NogoodBoyo on June 27, 2016, 10:58:30 PM
Has anybody heard anything from Woolly Mammoth about this?
Nogood "sorry Woolly, couldn't resist the low blow, isit" Boyo
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Blanco on June 27, 2016, 11:01:40 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

Don't worry that's not gonna happen. I hope Wales lose. That's got nothing to do with tonights result.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 27, 2016, 11:14:40 PM
Quote from: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.

Roy and Ray can motivate a team. I seem  to remember them getting a team without any stars to a European final. Roy was also successful with Switzerland. Let's keep the conversation sensible.

It's the players who can't even do the simple things, those that they do most weeks for their clubs, like pass the ball to their teammates.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Nero on June 27, 2016, 11:30:05 PM
I blame that crap brass band, kills all the atmosphere for England, When was the last time you heard England fans come up with a good chant all you get the bloody Great Escape tune. TIME TO SACK THE BRASS BAND
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 11:41:49 PM
Quote from: Nero on June 27, 2016, 11:30:05 PM
I blame that crap brass band, kills all the atmosphere for England, When was the last time you heard England fans come up with a good chant all you get the bloody Great Escape tune. TIME TO SACK THE BRASS BAND

Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the Welsh equivalent, The Barry Horns

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LWonUEEoVYc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LWonUEEoVYc)
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 07:20:56 AM
Surely it couldn't be a question of unrealistic expectations could it. The only team in the group who couldn't beat Russia, a scrambled result against a lowly ranked Wales (I know they have reached the quarters but let's be honest they got there by beating the might of NI) and a poor draw with Slovakia who promptly got thumped by Germany. We are actually not very good and simply don't have the players with the ability to compete at the upper levels. Look at the squads of the top teams and decide who of our team would get into their starting X1s. Add to that some basic errors in selection and tactics and you really can't be surprised at our inability to get very far in these comps.
I have read that our PL isn't the great league we think it is but it probably is as good as any and much of that is because of the overseas players in it. How would it be better if we got rid of them and played amongst ourselves, at least we get the opportunity to test our players against the best and let them see where they need to be if they wish to compete. Sterling has been slated because of his performances this time around but the question really is why was he there at all, with his obvious weaknesses in technical ability such as control, awareness and crossing but are there any really much better wingers out there to choose from.
Probably the most naturally talented player in our squad is 18 and got 5 minutes, not suggesting that he should have started but 5 minutes really. Wilshire has hardly played this year and it showed, Walker looked like a man dead on his feet from mental fatigue rather than physical but Clyne just sat on the bench instead of replacing Walker who no longer had the legs to get in behind when it was clear we needed Sturridge in the middle where his tricks and quick feet might have added something. Not suggesting that we would have gone much further anyway but how did we manage to get so much wrong, not just on the night but generally throughout the comp.   
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: dannyboi-ffc on June 28, 2016, 09:11:59 AM
Quote from: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 07:20:56 AM
Surely it couldn't be a question of unrealistic expectations could it. The only team in the group who couldn't beat Russia, a scrambled result against a lowly ranked Wales (I know they have reached the quarters but let's be honest they got there by beating the might of NI) and a poor draw with Slovakia who promptly got thumped by Germany. We are actually not very good and simply don't have the players with the ability to compete at the upper levels. Look at the squads of the top teams and decide who of our team would get into their starting X1s. Add to that some basic errors in selection and tactics and you really can't be surprised at our inability to get very far in these comps.
I have read that our PL isn't the great league we think it is but it probably is as good as any and much of that is because of the overseas players in it. How would it be better if we got rid of them and played amongst ourselves, at least we get the opportunity to test our players against the best and let them see where they need to be if they wish to compete. Sterling has been slated because of his performances this time around but the question really is why was he there at all, with his obvious weaknesses in technical ability such as control, awareness and crossing but are there any really much better wingers out there to choose from.
Probably the most naturally talented player in our squad is 18 and got 5 minutes, not suggesting that he should have started but 5 minutes really. Wilshire has hardly played this year and it showed, Walker looked like a man dead on his feet from mental fatigue rather than physical but Clyne just sat on the bench instead of replacing Walker who no longer had the legs to get in behind when it was clear we needed Sturridge in the middle where his tricks and quick feet might have added something. Not suggesting that we would have gone much further anyway but how did we manage to get so much wrong, not just on the night but generally throughout the comp.   

I think the fact so much went wrong meant Roy had to resign. There can be no excuses, the players aren't very good, we shouldn't expect to go further than the quarters but come on Roy.

For me he looks past it now. A great man, a great manager for Fulham but for England he has been awful and probably needs to retire or become a DOF somewhere.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 10:37:11 AM
Quote from: dannyboi-ffc on June 28, 2016, 09:11:59 AM
Quote from: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 07:20:56 AM
Surely it couldn't be a question of unrealistic expectations could it. The only team in the group who couldn't beat Russia, a scrambled result against a lowly ranked Wales (I know they have reached the quarters but let's be honest they got there by beating the might of NI) and a poor draw with Slovakia who promptly got thumped by Germany. We are actually not very good and simply don't have the players with the ability to compete at the upper levels. Look at the squads of the top teams and decide who of our team would get into their starting X1s. Add to that some basic errors in selection and tactics and you really can't be surprised at our inability to get very far in these comps.
I have read that our PL isn't the great league we think it is but it probably is as good as any and much of that is because of the overseas players in it. How would it be better if we got rid of them and played amongst ourselves, at least we get the opportunity to test our players against the best and let them see where they need to be if they wish to compete. Sterling has been slated because of his performances this time around but the question really is why was he there at all, with his obvious weaknesses in technical ability such as control, awareness and crossing but are there any really much better wingers out there to choose from.
Probably the most naturally talented player in our squad is 18 and got 5 minutes, not suggesting that he should have started but 5 minutes really. Wilshire has hardly played this year and it showed, Walker looked like a man dead on his feet from mental fatigue rather than physical but Clyne just sat on the bench instead of replacing Walker who no longer had the legs to get in behind when it was clear we needed Sturridge in the middle where his tricks and quick feet might have added something. Not suggesting that we would have gone much further anyway but how did we manage to get so much wrong, not just on the night but generally throughout the comp.   

I think the fact so much went wrong meant Roy had to resign. There can be no excuses, the players aren't very good, we shouldn't expect to go further than the quarters but come on Roy.

For me he looks past it now. A great man, a great manager for Fulham but for England he has been awful and probably needs to retire or become a DOF somewhere.

Agree and pleased he realised it was best to go before he was pushed.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: dannyboi-ffc on June 28, 2016, 10:55:29 AM
Quote from: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 10:37:11 AM
Quote from: dannyboi-ffc on June 28, 2016, 09:11:59 AM
Quote from: Beamer on June 28, 2016, 07:20:56 AM
Surely it couldn't be a question of unrealistic expectations could it. The only team in the group who couldn't beat Russia, a scrambled result against a lowly ranked Wales (I know they have reached the quarters but let's be honest they got there by beating the might of NI) and a poor draw with Slovakia who promptly got thumped by Germany. We are actually not very good and simply don't have the players with the ability to compete at the upper levels. Look at the squads of the top teams and decide who of our team would get into their starting X1s. Add to that some basic errors in selection and tactics and you really can't be surprised at our inability to get very far in these comps.
I have read that our PL isn't the great league we think it is but it probably is as good as any and much of that is because of the overseas players in it. How would it be better if we got rid of them and played amongst ourselves, at least we get the opportunity to test our players against the best and let them see where they need to be if they wish to compete. Sterling has been slated because of his performances this time around but the question really is why was he there at all, with his obvious weaknesses in technical ability such as control, awareness and crossing but are there any really much better wingers out there to choose from.
Probably the most naturally talented player in our squad is 18 and got 5 minutes, not suggesting that he should have started but 5 minutes really. Wilshire has hardly played this year and it showed, Walker looked like a man dead on his feet from mental fatigue rather than physical but Clyne just sat on the bench instead of replacing Walker who no longer had the legs to get in behind when it was clear we needed Sturridge in the middle where his tricks and quick feet might have added something. Not suggesting that we would have gone much further anyway but how did we manage to get so much wrong, not just on the night but generally throughout the comp.   

I think the fact so much went wrong meant Roy had to resign. There can be no excuses, the players aren't very good, we shouldn't expect to go further than the quarters but come on Roy.

For me he looks past it now. A great man, a great manager for Fulham but for England he has been awful and probably needs to retire or become a DOF somewhere.

Agree and pleased he realised it was best to go before he was pushed.

Judging from the speech he read I got the impression  he was leaving regardless of when or how we went out. His contract was up. He is quick if he prepared that speech after the game anyway, it must have been written in preparation.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Mince n Tatties on June 28, 2016, 12:38:42 PM
Quote from: NogoodBoyo on June 27, 2016, 10:58:30 PM
Has anybody heard anything from Woolly Mammoth about this?
Nogood "sorry Woolly, couldn't resist the low blow, isit" Boyo

Last seen heading a new expedition to the South Pole I believe. :022:
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: ffcthereligion on June 28, 2016, 12:41:18 PM
Petition to replay the match because we lost!!
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: jarv on June 28, 2016, 01:36:14 PM
As a passionate supporter of Scotland for decades, WELCOME TO MY WORLD.  I see parallels, the English players think they are better than they are. Similarly a long time ago Scotland had Dalglish, Strachan, Souness etc etc. They always went to finals full of hope and were home before the postcards (as they say).

Not entirely Roy's fault, I have said it many times, it does not matter who manages England, the outcome will always be the same. Easy passage to the finals, beating the likes of Andorra and the Isle of Wight, then...choke!
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: NogoodBoyo on June 28, 2016, 04:18:05 PM
The choke view is interesting.
If you look at the results since 1966 and pay particularly close attention to the key losses on penalties, it seems a given that English footballers are not winners.  In fact they are losers. 
Is it a national trait?  No.  English rugby players are winners (the Welsh in me finds it hard to write that, but it's an honest opinion based upon results).  English cricketers are sometimes winners.  And English athletes and cyclists can not be describes as losers either.
Who are the real winners?  In football look no further than Germany, Italy, France (sometimes) and Brazil (maybe no longer).  To me the best winning sports team of all time has to be New Zealand at rugby.  Skill, power, strength, passion, fitness coupled with a fierce will to win that overcomes all.
Nogood "sorry England - just can't cut it when it counts, isit" Boyo
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: One James stannard on June 28, 2016, 04:27:36 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside
[/quoted

I would love to give my honest reply to his pathetic post but I would be banned from using this forum!!!  :dft007:
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: filham on June 28, 2016, 06:00:56 PM
Can't think of a good word to say for England, they were awful in all aspects of the game, passing was terrible, shooting was hopeless, set pieces were all wasted and man for man they were individually outplayed.

We start qualification games for the World Cup in September and at this moment I think our best hope is to give big Sam Allardyce the job and for him to use Carrol at centre forward with a couple of good wingers and for them to play an old fashioned long ball game. OK not a classic approach but at least we would go down fighting against teams like Iceland.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: YoungsBitter on June 28, 2016, 06:18:43 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 27, 2016, 11:14:40 PM
Quote from: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.

Roy and Ray can motivate a team. I seem  to remember them getting a team without any stars to a European final. Roy was also successful with Switzerland. Let's keep the conversation sensible.

It's the players who can't even do the simple things, those that they do most weeks for their clubs, like pass the ball to their teammates.
I think once again we are tempted to be generous with Roy based on that sentimental belief from his Fulham days. I think the last 4 years has shown, sadly, that Roy is a one trick pony. It worked with a humble and disorganized Swiss squad but their crowning glory under Hodgson was qualifying to a World Cup/Euros  in 1994-6 based primarily in being unbeaten through draws. It worked with a humble and disorganized Fulham squad to get to the final of Europa. However many of us also remember the mind numbing games with Roy with no ideas or creativity - "how about a sub Roy?".
He was unsuccessful at Liverpool for the same reasons he was unsuccessful at England. Lacking in plan B or C and does not have the ability to inspire guys 45 years his junior.
Conte has shown what coaching and leadership is like and his Italian team of average and quite old players have responded. I think the constant selection issues - chopping and changing, no defined style, poor judgement through sticking to favorites ( Hart? Wilshere? Rooney? Lailana?) where all the evidence was that there were better options which then demotivates the others. Poor use of subs except when desperate against Wales.

Yesterday was all you ever needed to see about Hodgson's limitations as a national team coach. Rigid, complacent in his own knowledge, didnt bother scouting Iceland at all, clueless to change when obvious to everyone the system was not working, Wilshere for Dier was like for like, Vardy was wasted wide left as Sturridge was wasted wide right just so Roy's great master stroke  of playing Rooney in midfield could be continued. Kane taking corners and free kicks? Rashford did more in 6 minutes than Kane did all game...

He may be, as we all think on this Board, a really nice guy. I just think he should not have been the England coach still after the previous problems.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: filham on June 28, 2016, 06:40:02 PM
I wouldn't blame Roy for that terrible performance, man for man Iceland were better than us on the night.
I would expect that England team if sent onto the pitch without a manager or coach to be able to beat Iceland.

Roy has done the honourable thing and resigned, the players should now issue an apology and offer to play all world cup qualifiers unpaid.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 28, 2016, 07:08:25 PM
Quote from: YoungsBitter on June 28, 2016, 06:18:43 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 27, 2016, 11:14:40 PM
Quote from: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.

Roy and Ray can motivate a team. I seem  to remember them getting a team without any stars to a European final. Roy was also successful with Switzerland. Let's keep the conversation sensible.

It's the players who can't even do the simple things, those that they do most weeks for their clubs, like pass the ball to their teammates.
I think once again we are tempted to be generous with Roy based on that sentimental belief from his Fulham days. I think the last 4 years has shown, sadly, that Roy is a one trick pony. It worked with a humble and disorganized Swiss squad but their crowning glory under Hodgson was qualifying to a World Cup/Euros  in 1994-6 based primarily in being unbeaten through draws. It worked with a humble and disorganized Fulham squad to get to the final of Europa. However many of us also remember the mind numbing games with Roy with no ideas or creativity - "how about a sub Roy?".
He was unsuccessful at Liverpool for the same reasons he was unsuccessful at England. Lacking in plan B or C and does not have the ability to inspire guys 45 years his junior.
Conte has shown what coaching and leadership is like and his Italian team of average and quite old players have responded. I think the constant selection issues - chopping and changing, no defined style, poor judgement through sticking to favorites ( Hart? Wilshere? Rooney? Lailana?) where all the evidence was that there were better options which then demotivates the others. Poor use of subs except when desperate against Wales.

Yesterday was all you ever needed to see about Hodgson's limitations as a national team coach. Rigid, complacent in his own knowledge, didnt bother scouting Iceland at all, clueless to change when obvious to everyone the system was not working, Wilshere for Dier was like for like, Vardy was wasted wide left as Sturridge was wasted wide right just so Roy's great master stroke  of playing Rooney in midfield could be continued. Kane taking corners and free kicks? Rashford did more in 6 minutes than Kane did all game...

He may be, as we all think on this Board, a really nice guy. I just think he should not have been the England coach still after the previous problems.

Should players for England need 'inspiring' to ensure they pass the ball to each other?

It was not team selection or tactics that lost the game. A pub side after a good lunch would have shown more effort.
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: rubbernecca on June 28, 2016, 07:22:46 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 28, 2016, 07:08:25 PM
Quote from: YoungsBitter on June 28, 2016, 06:18:43 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 27, 2016, 11:14:40 PM
Quote from: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.

Roy and Ray can motivate a team. I seem  to remember them getting a team without any stars to a European final. Roy was also successful with Switzerland. Let's keep the conversation sensible.

It's the players who can't even do the simple things, those that they do most weeks for their clubs, like pass the ball to their teammates.
I think once again we are tempted to be generous with Roy based on that sentimental belief from his Fulham days. I think the last 4 years has shown, sadly, that Roy is a one trick pony. It worked with a humble and disorganized Swiss squad but their crowning glory under Hodgson was qualifying to a World Cup/Euros  in 1994-6 based primarily in being unbeaten through draws. It worked with a humble and disorganized Fulham squad to get to the final of Europa. However many of us also remember the mind numbing games with Roy with no ideas or creativity - "how about a sub Roy?".
He was unsuccessful at Liverpool for the same reasons he was unsuccessful at England. Lacking in plan B or C and does not have the ability to inspire guys 45 years his junior.
Conte has shown what coaching and leadership is like and his Italian team of average and quite old players have responded. I think the constant selection issues - chopping and changing, no defined style, poor judgement through sticking to favorites ( Hart? Wilshere? Rooney? Lailana?) where all the evidence was that there were better options which then demotivates the others. Poor use of subs except when desperate against Wales.

Yesterday was all you ever needed to see about Hodgson's limitations as a national team coach. Rigid, complacent in his own knowledge, didnt bother scouting Iceland at all, clueless to change when obvious to everyone the system was not working, Wilshere for Dier was like for like, Vardy was wasted wide left as Sturridge was wasted wide right just so Roy's great master stroke  of playing Rooney in midfield could be continued. Kane taking corners and free kicks? Rashford did more in 6 minutes than Kane did all game...

He may be, as we all think on this Board, a really nice guy. I just think he should not have been the England coach still after the previous problems.

Should players for England need 'inspiring' to ensure they pass the ball to each other?

It was not team selection or tactics that lost the game. A pub side after a good lunch would have shown more effort.

You need a starting 11. Defined roles. Without that, there's confusion and everything just goes to pot.  The tactics, man management and team selection were terrible. Kane was visibly nervous and made to take set pieces?  WTF?!
Title: Re: Roy resign, Rooney retire. That was unacceptable
Post by: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 28, 2016, 08:22:42 PM
Quote from: rubbernecca on June 28, 2016, 07:22:46 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 28, 2016, 07:08:25 PM
Quote from: YoungsBitter on June 28, 2016, 06:18:43 PM
Quote from: Apprentice to the Maestro on June 27, 2016, 11:14:40 PM
Quote from: J.Perkins on June 27, 2016, 10:48:03 PM
Quote from: Rhys Lightning 63 on June 27, 2016, 10:20:20 PM
BTW, after all the s**t you gave us over 'one man team', you can shove your 'we can all support Wales now' nonsense up your backside

The Welsh care more about England failing than the Welsh succeeding.

Roy and Ray can motivate a team. I seem  to remember them getting a team without any stars to a European final. Roy was also successful with Switzerland. Let's keep the conversation sensible.

It's the players who can't even do the simple things, those that they do most weeks for their clubs, like pass the ball to their teammates.
I think once again we are tempted to be generous with Roy based on that sentimental belief from his Fulham days. I think the last 4 years has shown, sadly, that Roy is a one trick pony. It worked with a humble and disorganized Swiss squad but their crowning glory under Hodgson was qualifying to a World Cup/Euros  in 1994-6 based primarily in being unbeaten through draws. It worked with a humble and disorganized Fulham squad to get to the final of Europa. However many of us also remember the mind numbing games with Roy with no ideas or creativity - "how about a sub Roy?".
He was unsuccessful at Liverpool for the same reasons he was unsuccessful at England. Lacking in plan B or C and does not have the ability to inspire guys 45 years his junior.
Conte has shown what coaching and leadership is like and his Italian team of average and quite old players have responded. I think the constant selection issues - chopping and changing, no defined style, poor judgement through sticking to favorites ( Hart? Wilshere? Rooney? Lailana?) where all the evidence was that there were better options which then demotivates the others. Poor use of subs except when desperate against Wales.

Yesterday was all you ever needed to see about Hodgson's limitations as a national team coach. Rigid, complacent in his own knowledge, didnt bother scouting Iceland at all, clueless to change when obvious to everyone the system was not working, Wilshere for Dier was like for like, Vardy was wasted wide left as Sturridge was wasted wide right just so Roy's great master stroke  of playing Rooney in midfield could be continued. Kane taking corners and free kicks? Rashford did more in 6 minutes than Kane did all game...

He may be, as we all think on this Board, a really nice guy. I just think he should not have been the England coach still after the previous problems.

Should players for England need 'inspiring' to ensure they pass the ball to each other?

It was not team selection or tactics that lost the game. A pub side after a good lunch would have shown more effort.

You need a starting 11. Defined roles. Without that, there's confusion and everything just goes to pot.  The tactics, man management and team selection were terrible. Kane was visibly nervous and made to take set pieces?  WTF?!

I think that you are being excessively generous to the players. There is no room for excuses about team selection, formation or tactics that can explain how badly they played individually and as a team.