After watching a few games now pundits aside as I tend to switch off for them after game nor watch pre match or half time.
Is any one else of the mindset that the BBC is poor..?
To me Glenn Hoddle is one of the best and probably more knowledgeable of the whole bunch.
Kevin Kilbane was pretty good yesterday too.
Had to turn the volume off with Mark Lawrenson as so negative he was killing the game.
thoughts ...?
I have 2 admit I quite like Mark Lawrenson and his dry humour. No doubt someone will come back with the question 'What humour?' !!
Glen Hoddle out of all the pundits is technically the best in my opinion, there are others that are decent, but there are a couple I would rather turn off the volume.
Phil Neville is having a shocker today. Ball whistles past post and he describes it as over the bar. His half time remarks began with "For me, Mexico won the first half". Yes Phil, for everyone else too, as they are 1-0 up.
Glen Hoddle is the best for me.
Not keen on either Neville of Roy Keane.
Keane's a right misery. Always has to find fault with something.
Most commentators and pundits simply talk too much and all too often state the bleedin' obvious.
Roy Keane very poor.
Astonishing really why all these people are out there. They could do the job sat in London with modern technology.
The worst is Five Live. Its 'news' team are just desperate to get involved in a sporting event and send reports around sounding like they are experts. That Rachel Burden on a bike morning was a hoot. Just so bad. And we pay.
And why the love affair with Savage? Arguably the most disliked player the Prem has ever seen, they continue to use him as an expert. He simply is not, very, bright. And looks like he belongs in a circus.
Watch with the sound off. Or in my case, don't watch at all.
PS: Ruiz was pretty anonymous today. Mitro missed a sitter. Roll on the new season, can't wait.
I never listen to any pundit as they all have different opinions to me. Not that they are wrong but neither am i
Quote from: Buffalo76 on June 17, 2018, 07:14:01 PM
Keane's a right misery. Always has to find fault with something.
Cannot stand the surly Keane, charmless, no social skills, and that's just his good side.
Makes Stan Collymore look almost human.
He must know somebody in a high place. No wonder Brian Clough punched him in training once whilst at Forest.
Quote from: MikeW on June 17, 2018, 09:06:58 PM
Astonishing really why all these people are out there. They could do the job sat in London with modern technology.
The worst is Five Live. Its 'news' team are just desperate to get involved in a sporting event and send reports around sounding like they are experts. That Rachel Burden on a bike morning was a hoot. Just so bad. And we pay.
And why the love affair with Savage? Arguably the most disliked player the Prem has ever seen, they continue to use him as an expert. He simply is not, very, bright. And looks like he belongs in a circus.
Watch with the sound off. Or in my case, don't watch at all.
PS: Ruiz was pretty anonymous today. Mitro missed a sitter. Roll on the new season, can't wait.
The squeaky voiced Savage is a nightmare, not only did players and fans dislike him, the referees and linos disliked him even more.
Best comment by far was I think Mark Lawrenson when a player again went down as if he had been attacked by sharks and the comment was another 'dislocated shoe lace'.
But on the whole there are just too many pundits now. We don't need them or want them. Just have the commentator and a summariser and that will do. I don't need a load of toss pots telling me what I already know.
thought Ally McCoist was rather good.
Hope it's not Hoddle for our game later, cant stand him doing England games when much of his time managing the side was a shambles
Saw Hangeland the last couple of days on the tele while I was in Norway. Couldn't tell you what he was saying but he looked good.
I did like Bilic's comment re the outcome of Brazil.and Switzerland: "Why should I care?'
Quote from: Southcoastffc on June 18, 2018, 08:29:17 AM
I did like Bilic's comment re the outcome of Brazil.and Switzerland: "Why should I care?'
Must admit his comment did make the Grumpy Household crease up with laughter 064.gif
Roy Keane looks Orange. Or is it just my tv.
Quote from: Buffalo76 on June 17, 2018, 04:09:49 PM
I have 2 admit I quite like Mark Lawrenson and his dry humour. No doubt someone will come back with the question 'What humour?' !!
I totally agree. I also agree with most of his opinions. He got a telling off once from the BBC hierarchy when commenting on both the Bender brothers playing for their country....'You don't often get two benders in the same team....'
The worst for me is Ian Dowie.
092.gif
Haven't heard a single bad or decent commentary since I found out where the volume control was. Really wish there was an option to silence the commentary and still get the atmosphere but that is the only downer. Find some of the 'expert' panel banter bordering on the banal but have always enjoyed Lee Dixon's POVs. Cannot stand Lineker at any price and just wish BBC would get someone in for a lot less money and much better value.
Lineker is another talentless one. It's not what you know it's who you. When he first started, all those years ago on match of the day, I thought to myself, he is the worst I have ever seen in the roll he is in as what I suppose is the Anchor man. He had no personality and was more wooden than a Woodpecker pecking wood in a Timber Yard.
I thought he won't last five minutes, they will offload him.
But clearly it's not what you know it's who you know.
Because all these years later he is still that plank of wood and just as boring.
Quote from: Southcoastffc on June 17, 2018, 08:24:53 PM
Most commentators and pundits simply talk too much and all too often state the bleedin' obvious.
0001.jpeg 0001.jpeg 0001.jpeg 0001.jpeg 0001.jpeg 0001.jpeg
Quote from: Woolly Mammoth on June 18, 2018, 10:15:20 AM
Lineker is another talentless one. It's not what you know it's who you. When he first started, all those years ago on match of the day, I thought to myself, he is the worst I have ever seen in the roll he is in as what I suppose is the Anchor man. He had no personality and was more wooden than a Woodpecker pecking wood in a Timber Yard.
I thought he won't last five minutes, they will offload him.
But clearly it's not what you know it's who you know.
Because all these years later he is still that plank of wood and just as boring.
0001.jpeg
Quote from: Lighthouse on June 17, 2018, 11:26:13 PM
Best comment by far was I think Mark Lawrenson when a player again went down as if he had been attacked by sharks and the comment was another 'dislocated shoe lace'.
But on the whole there are just too many pundits now. We don't need them or want them. Just have the commentator and a summariser and that will do. I don't need a load of toss pots telling me what I already know.
0001.jpeg
it's all about opinion and I loathe the ITV save for lee dixon and ane aluko, the rest especially hoddle are pants. Hoddle and in fairness dowie (who is worse) bring nothing to the party except to say exctly what we can see for ourselves. BBC is rther more grown up but a bit humourless at times.I always like danny murphy no matter what he says because he was a star for us!!!!
Hoddle for me is very insightful.
Interestingly presents a players perspective rather than a managers one.
Quote from: Milo on June 18, 2018, 06:00:32 PM
Hoddle for me is very insightful.
Interestingly presents a players perspective rather than a managers one.
Goodness! We must be seeing a different man.
It's the same in Germany, they all seem to like the sound of their own voices.
Admittedly not seen him this World Cup commentate - I'm going off the league games I've seen him cover.
Thoughts on derbys new manager?
Lampard seems reasonably to the point. Certainly not a complete air head like Ferdinand but still feel this Derby move is going to be a disaster
I quite like Martin Keown, very calm and contributes good comments
