Friends of Fulham

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: RaySmith on June 14, 2019, 03:56:16 PM

Title: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: RaySmith on June 14, 2019, 03:56:16 PM
Another very soft pen given against Scotland in the Womens' World Cup, and then denied a clear pen, and another shout as good as the ones given against them, for handball, which would have made the result 2-2 , instead of 2-1 to Japan. So much for VAR meaning fairer results. Grrrr!!!!
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: Stoneleigh Loyalist on June 14, 2019, 04:05:47 PM
Some fast players and plenty of effort but no real quality -goal excepted.
Similar to the England game Japan should have been out of sight first half.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: RaySmith on June 14, 2019, 04:21:04 PM
But still very badly done by re pen decisions. Scotland should have has about three, while Japan's was debatable at best, and given after VAR - not used for any  of the Scottish pen shouts.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: Stoneleigh Loyalist on June 14, 2019, 04:28:06 PM
I am not anti-Scotland but the funny thing is that I shouted penalty as soon as the incident occurred.
Pre-VAR there would be plenty of games where it would have been given without hesitation.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: RaySmith on June 14, 2019, 04:38:24 PM
I thought it soft on immediate viewing, and VAR showed it at best only a technical foul - ie she put her hand on her back wih no pressure, but the player dived, whereas I did shout out at two of the late Scotland pen shouts, and they weren't even granted VAR.

And that's allied to the  pen for England v Scotland, for a 'technical ' handball, based on the new  'unnatural body position rule 'which was a complete  joke, and probably would never have been granted but for VAR.


Scotland very unlucky with ref decisions, which were ********terrible imo.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: Nero on June 14, 2019, 10:19:29 PM
there's been some terrible VAR decision the French plenty the other day, the French player jumps in 2 footed on the ball, goes on the air and hit Norway player on the arm and gets the plenty after being reviewed 
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: toshes mate on June 15, 2019, 09:27:38 AM
Terrible referees and officials, be they on the pitch or sat in front of TV monitors, are terrible, period.  The reasons why they are so poor is because the game is not injecting support via any number of key measures into grass roots developments (i.e. the very important base of any sport).  One day the elites of football will start choking on all the money they have blindly, selfishly, and greedily accumulated or squandered and scream ' f..o..u..l' but nobody competent to make a judgement will be around to help them out.  They will have gotten exactly what they deserve.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: Bill2 on June 15, 2019, 11:00:07 AM
Blatant penalty for Scotland, the Japanese one was soft, similar to the Liverpool one at Fulham this year.
Title: Re: Scotland Women- victim of terrible referreeing, WWC
Post by: bobbo on June 15, 2019, 12:49:05 PM
Quote from: Bill2 on June 15, 2019, 11:00:07 AM
Blatant penalty for Scotland, the Japanese one was soft, similar to the Liverpool one at Fulham this year.
Bill , like you FFC runing through my veins, but, so many dont think that tug by rico was a pen . IT MOST CERTAINLY WAS, trouble is we are used to those situations being a bit 50/50 , he had his hand on his shoulder and tugged albeit slight , it just is contrary to the laws of the game , its a shame it was against us on this occasion but i would like to see more decosions like it.