Harvey

[steed]

Would anyone take Harvey Elliott back if available?

[bencher]

Yes, he's a very talented footballer. I've no idea what's going on with him at Villa right now so that would be part of the due diligence. But this is never happening.

[H4usuallysitting]

I'm not sure the club would welcome him back....Sess going & returning was very different - no fuss, all done very professionally

[WindyCity]

Yes, he's a very talented footballer. I've no idea what's going on with him at Villa right now so that would be part of the due diligence. But this is never happening.

Agree, probably won't happen, but if available, I'd have him back, even though generally I'm not a big fan of bringing back players.

[cmg]

Interesting situation at Villa.Shows the potential snags for these conditional loan moves.

I believe that if he makes 10 appearences for Villa they have to buy him at season's end for £35million. He has currently made 5 apearences.
What seemed like good deal for Villa (he is a pretty good player), now seems not so good because of a number of possible reasons. One, or a combination of, a) he's not as good as they thought he was, b)they now think they have better answers in his position, c) they can't afford the agreed fee. If they starve him of appearences until January, Liverpool might agree to take him back.
I don't see how we would be involved in any of this. He's not going anywhere on a free.

[Fulham 442]

No

[Finnans Right Peg]

Where would he play if he did sign

[wback100]

Where would he play if he did sign

He could do a job in the role that Lukic plays (as a backup) or the one Iwobi is currently excelling in (again, as a backup, on current form).

He's good off the bench, and could be useful playing a role to unlock a goal if we needed one in the last 20 mins. But yeah, funny that he wouldn't be any closer to playing for us than he is for Villa.

Not that any of this would happen.

[St Eve]

No

[bobbo]

I don't think he's a lot better than what we already have . But it probably won't ever happen anyway .

[Bassey the warrior]

It's clear Harvey and Fabio should've stuck around a bit longer, they have stalled.

[Colton F.C.]

Jao yes, Mitro yes, Fabio maybe, Gingernuts NO!

[Logicalman]

Not at all.
And if they're asking 35M for him, they can go do one, afaic, I'd rather have Roberts back!

[AshfordFFC]

not for me - especially with the talent that will be in front of him!

[Ludlow Richard]

Long article on BBC Sport website explaining why it's all gone wrong for Elliott at Villa.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c0q51l742lyo

[Carborundum]

Long article on BBC Sport website explaining why it's all gone wrong for Elliott at Villa.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c0q51l742lyo

Helpful link that explains he's already played for Liverpool and Villa this season, so a move for him in January isn't on the cards.  He's good and with Liverpool not exactly pulling up trees, a switch back might suit all parties.

[demeant0r]

Long article on BBC Sport website explaining why it's all gone wrong for Elliott at Villa.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c0q51l742lyo

Helpful link that explains he's already played for Liverpool and Villa this season, so a move for him in January isn't on the cards.  He's good and with Liverpool not exactly pulling up trees, a switch back might suit all parties.

Will the management and/or fans welcome him back? Let's not forget that part of the reason why Sess (and Palhinha) is so loved here is because he signed a new contract so that we could get the max transfer fee for him from Spurs, something neither Harvey Elliot nor Carvalho did.

[sunburywhite]

I would have Harvey back

Imagine the goals a 6 ft 3+1⁄2 in (1.92 m) tall white invisible rabbit can score

[Southcoastffc]

Long article on BBC Sport website explaining why it's all gone wrong for Elliott at Villa.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c0q51l742lyo

Helpful link that explains he's already played for Liverpool and Villa this season, so a move for him in January isn't on the cards.  He's good and with Liverpool not exactly pulling up trees, a switch back might suit all parties.

Will the management and/or fans welcome him back? Let's not forget that part of the reason why Sess (and Palhinha) is so loved here is because he signed a new contract so that we could get the max transfer fee for him from Spurs, something neither Harvey Elliot nor Carvalho did.

To be fair to Carvalho he could have well gone from us in January but stayed and performed admirably until the end of the season.

[Coastwalker]

I would have Harvey back

Imagine the goals a 6 ft 3+1⁄2 in (1.92 m) tall white invisible rabbit can score

🤣🐰