News:

Use a VPN to stream games Safely and Securely 🔒
A Virtual Private Network can also allow you to
watch games Not being broadcast in the UK For
more Information and how to Sign Up go to
https://go.nordvpn.net/SH4FE

Main Menu


Citehs disallowed 'goal'

Started by Southcoastffc, November 21, 2026, 06:01:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Southcoastffc

I was interested to see exactly what the rules say:


A goalkeeper is deemed to have control of the ball with their hand(s)/arm(s) when:
• The ball is between their hands or arms.
• The ball is trapped between their hand(s)/arm(s) and another surface, such as the ground or their own body.
• They hold the ball in an outstretched open hand.
• They bounce it on the ground or throw it into the air.

So, well done ref and the other officials.
The world is made up of electrons, protons, neurons, possibly muons and, definitely, morons.

bill taylors apprentice

The ref said no, so it's no goal and he was correct.

There will be some, including the pundits who say it should have stood but we all know too many players, pundits and commonators don't know the LOTG!

AshfordFFC

Quote from: bill taylors apprentice on November 21, 2026, 06:08:46 PMThe ref said no, so it's no goal and he was correct.

There will be some, including the pundits who say it should have stood but we all know too many players, pundits and commonators don't know the LOTG!

100% agree.  I was watching the game and thought straight away it would be disallowed however if VAR did a check, why not spot what happened with Muniz during the build up as it was never repeated but looked like an albow?


Southcoastffc

As an aside,  I thought the referee was good today. The incident above excepted, I don't recall any contentious decisions.
The world is made up of electrons, protons, neurons, possibly muons and, definitely, morons.

RaySmith

Commentators on the stream I was watching, and in the studio,  going on and on about how it should have been given as a goal!

Thailand Mick

I think Leno was lucky because he didn't have a grip on the ball and would have dropped it but he had both hands touching the ball and that is deemed by the rules as good enough. We have all seen the injustices we have suffered against them on at least a couple of games so they can cry about it I don't give a t*ss.


Andrew

The rules were applied correctly, for once.

However, it's ridiculous and needs a bit of a rethink imo.

If the keeper doesn't have proper control of the ball then it means no forward can challenge. I agree you can't be allowed to kick it out of his hands if he really has it but leno didn't.

The pundits are a menace though, no good saying it should be allowed if the rules are applied correctly. It's amazing how little the pundits actually know.

FFC In Oz

Quote from: Southcoastffc on November 21, 2026, 06:01:53 PMI was interested to see exactly what the rules say:


A goalkeeper is deemed to have control of the ball with their hand(s)/arm(s) when:
• The ball is between their hands or arms.
• The ball is trapped between their hand(s)/arm(s) and another surface, such as the ground or their own body.
• They hold the ball in an outstretched open hand.
• They bounce it on the ground or throw it into the air.

So, well done ref and the other officials.

Initially I thought it was very soft.

Then at HT the analysts put those laws up and I posted them in the matchday thread.

So by the letter of the law, right decision - Shay Given was one of the analysts and said so too

JimmyConway

Part of me is not totally convinced Leno is ever in control of the ball ? Think Leno was close to potentially an howler? Happy it was disallowed though.


Dodgin

Foul all the way, two hand rule

Twig

Quote from: Andrew on <strong>Today</strong> at 10:09:18 AMThe rules were applied correctly, for once.

However, it's ridiculous and needs a bit of a rethink imo.

If the keeper doesn't have proper control of the ball then it means no forward can challenge. I agree you can't be allowed to kick it out of his hands if he really has it but leno didn't.

The pundits are a menace though, no good saying it should be allowed if the rules are applied correctly. It's amazing how little the pundits actually know.

The commentators and pundits yesterday were beyond awful.

Somerset Fulham

Quote from: Dodgin on <strong>Today</strong> at 10:57:02 AMFoul all the way, two hand rule

I thought this as well but it seems that it is actually now a one hand rule.


SimonDaviesEnjoyer

To me it looked like Haaland kicked it when Leno had hand on it, but what do I know.

WolverineFFC

Quote from: SimonDaviesEnjoyer on <strong>Today</strong> at 12:07:28 PMTo me it looked like Haaland kicked it when Leno had hand on it, but what do I know.

I don't think there is even a question that was the case. All the consternation was "experts" not understanding the rules.

SimonDaviesEnjoyer

The commentators made it sound like an injustice to rival City's 120 convictions for financial cheating. It was mad to listen to.


Cowperc

I was listening to the match and didn't get to see a replay until hours later. The commentators had me thinking Fulham got away with murder. So, I was pleasantly surprised when I finally saw it for myself. Leno clearly had both hands on the ball (which was not moving) when Haaland's left toe jostles it loose. It seems clear as day to me that it was called properly.

Holders

So under today's interpretation, the George Best/Gordon Banks goal, which was disputed at the time, would have been rightly disallowed.
Non sumus statione ferriviaria

Luka

The rules are the rules.
Northerners always need something to moan about in their grim little world.
Today it's a goal that never was.