Compare the players

[Rhys Lightning 63]

Following my 'Compare The Teams' thread a few days ago, here's a little different one. Two Fulham players. One from the past and one from the present team. Pick one. To make this clear I want the current player based on form THIS SEASON and the past player based on when they were at their greatest for Fulham.

To start the ball rolling we'll start with the striker position

Brian McBride 05/06 season
or
Dimitar Berbatov

[fulhamben]

so the form of berba is 2 goals and constanly injured so mcbride all day long for me.