Player of the season so far

[Patrick]

Berbatov....pure class........closely followed by Reither...German dependability.....

[aFFCn_Fan]

Nothing controversial for me...Reither, followed by Duff (in early part of season), then Berbs.  

[malcbridger]

Riether. I agree with Northern White, had Duff not got injured he was the most consistent up to that point.

[Flupp]

Riether  :German-flag:

[epsomraver]

Sidwell by a country mile.

[Mr K.Dilkington]

Riether. I can't think of a game i've watched this season where I thought he played poorly.

[Aaron]

Riether, definitely. 

Berbatov will win it though.

[Danny]

Berbatov

http://www.capelloindex.com/en/rankings?league=8&season=2012&matchday=21

[EJL]

Berbatov

http://www.capelloindex.com/en/rankings?league=8&season=2012&matchday=21

No defenders in the top twenty seems a bit odd.

[farfouille]

Such a nice thread... for a poll! ;)

It is surprising to me how everyone thinks Berba is "different class" but he hardly made it to top 5. I have never seen him that consistent in Manchester United, yet here he is in the shadow of a barely known full back. :) I hope by the end of the season our Man of the Season would be someone who changes games, hopefully a midfielder.

[JackyFulham90]

Sidwell has surprised me he has been really good this season

[Ordar]

Got to be Reither. Played well in every game. Best Fullback I've ever seen us have

[Danny]

Berbatov

http://www.capelloindex.com/en/rankings?league=8&season=2012&matchday=21

No defenders in the top twenty seems a bit odd.

 Find out the TOP 20 players in Bundesliga and see how many defenders are there.
Chelsea and Man City didn't pass even the group stages in CL. Man Utd and Arsenal must probably will follow them soon , so where are the good defenders !? If any they are only few imo. Baines for example

[Scrumpy]

Sidwell for me. I don't think I've ever seen a player with more of an 'engine' on him. He is a constant menace to the opposition when they have the ball. We need someone like that just as much as we need Berba and Ruiz when we have the ball.  000en.gif

[Danny]

http://www.premierleague.com/en-gb/players/ea-sports-player-performance-index.html?paramSearchTerm=&paramClubId=&paramSeason=2012-2013&paramPosition=&paramEaBreakdownType=ACCUMULATIVE&paramGameWeek=1&paramItemsPerPage=40&paramSelectedPageIndex=1

R       LR    Player            Club    POS        A.AV    INDEX
1       1    Robin van Persie    MUN    Forward        480
2       2    Patrice Evra    MUN    Defender        399
3       7    Leighton Baines    EVE    Defender        376
4       3    Yaya Toure    MCI    Midfielder        373
5       4    Juan Mata    CHE    Midfielder                371
6       8    Santi Cazorla    ARS    Midfielder        352
7       5    Gareth Bale    TOT    Midfielder       349
8       13    Steven Pienaar    EVE    Midfielder        342
9       6    Carlos Tevez    MCI    Forward       334
10       52    Luis Suarez    LIV    Forward        329
11       10    Marouane Fellaini    EVE    Midfielder        328
12       14    Michael Carrick    MUN    Midfielder        321
13       11    Fernando Torres    CHE    Forward        320
14       21    Aaron Lennon    TOT    Midfielder        320
15       18    Steven Gerrard    LIV    Midfielder       316
16       9    Wayne Rooney    MUN    Forward       315
17       15    Eden Hazard    CHE    Midfielder       312
18       12    Miguel Michu    SWA    Midfielder        310
19       30    Jonny Evans    MUN    Defender        303
20       16    Mikel Arteta    ARS    Midfielder        302
21       19    David Silva      MCI    Midfielder        300
22       17    Dimitar Berbatov    FUL    Forward       293
23       25    Demba Ba    NEW    Forward       287
24       28    Leon Osman    EVE    Midfielder        285
25       29    Phil Jagielka    EVE    Defender        285
26       23    Rafael Da Silva    MUN    Defender        284
27       22    Gary Cahill    CHE    Defender        278
28       20    Branislav Ivanovic    CHE    Defender        274
29       26    Steven Fletcher    SUN    Forward        273
30       37    Wayne Routledge    SWA    Midfielder        273
31       35    Ashley Williams    SWA    Defender        271
32       27    Jermain Defoe    TOT    Forward        270
33       88    Sergio Aguero    MCI    Forward        270
34       64    Pablo Zabaleta    MCI    Defender        264
35       41    Joe Hart            MCI    Goalkeeper       262
36       31    Anthony Pilkington NOR    Midfielder        262
37       39    Robert Snodgrass NOR    Midfielder        260
38       24    Jonas Olsson    WBA    Defender        257
39       33    Petr Cech            CHE    Goalkeeper        257
40       36    Rio Ferdinand    MUN    Defender        255

[St Eve]

Berbatov, Reither, Ruiz, Duff, Kaca

[MasterHaynes]

Reither is certainly the only player that has consistently played at the level required and lost count the number of goal line clearances he has made

[Nightwind15]

It has to be Sidwell for me.  He is rock solid, not a glamor guy but someone you cannot win without.